Many are encouraged by the sudden surge in movement on comprehensive Immigration Reform – first from a rare bipartisan “Gang of 8” Senators, and the day after, from President Obama, who traveled to Las Vegas to unveil his proposal, which is essentially the same proposal as he advanced during his first term.
Why now and not then?
The momentum comes because Republicans are horrified by the demographic shifts that have left them out in the cold in the Presidential elections of 2008 and 2012. They don’t like the optics that have emerged from anti-immigrant stance that is exemplified by Arizona, Alabama, by Romney’s call for making life so miserable that undocumented immigrants choose to “self-deport,” and his promise to repeal the Dream Act if it had passed, and calls to impeach Obama for using his Presidential discretion to give Dreamers a reprieve.
So now, despite the fact that Obama has basically proposed the same comprehensive immigration reform as he did two years ago, Republicans – led by Sen. John McCain who was for immigration reform before he was against it, and now is for it again – are amazingly open to the idea of reform.
Except that it is all about “optics”. Republicans do not really care to ease the path for nondocumented immigrants – their corporate donors benefit from being able to exploit cheap labor, they benefit now from the census advantage in giving them more seats in the House, without the thorny problem of allowing these people to vote, and they have benefited from using undocumented immigrants as scapegoats for economic problems, feeding the lies that these non-tax paying individuals (when they actually do pay taxes) are getting free rides in public schools and hospitals.
Democrats seem willing to fall into the Catch-22 that Republicans are orchestrating, which is their demand for a prerequisite before the first undocumented immigrant can even start the new promise: strengthening the border. But this is a subjective, and probably insurmountable obstacle.
Indeed, Republicans have blasted Obama over and over during the last campaign for “failing” to protect the border, when there is all the evidence to the contrary (facts, evidence don’t actually matter).
Obama has deported 2 million undocumented immigrants in the last four years – more than his predecessors – and in fact, has come under attack by Latinos for his aggressive deportation policy. He has created the tightest border controls of any president, tripling funding to defend the border, spending $18 billion a year, more funding than any other law enforcement agency (including the FBI). Still, the Republicans charge that he is weak on border control.
So this is all a red-herring, and will give Republicans the appearance of not being as rabidly biased when in fact they have no intention whatsoever of making the process of becoming a citizen more efficient or rational, fair or just. (this is the same tactic Republicans are using in canceling out any sensible gun control reform: where all of a sudden, commonsense controls on assault weapons and high-capacity ammo clips are subordinated to incarcerating the mentally ill and controlling violent video games and movies).
They have no intention of creating a system where these individuals, with no legal status and living in shadows and in fear every day, will somehow become citizens with the power to vote. Because Republicans realize that the new citizens are likely to vote Democratic. While their hope was that Latinos, who are predominantly Catholic, would support Republican extreme social policies, the exit polls have shown surprisingly that Latinos side with Democrats on abortion, gay marriage and gun control. Oops. The only segment of the Hispanic community that tends to be Republican are the Cuban-Americans in Florida, who are completely separated from the rest of Latinos in the way they are handed legal status and citizenship just by touching US shores. Yet it is Sen. Mark Rubio of Florida (whose grandparents claimed to be fleeing Castro but came before Castro was in power), who is taking the lead for Republicans.
The talking points have come down from Republican strategists: Don’t use the term “illegals” or “aliens” or “anchor baby” or “electric fence” or “send them all back”
The reason we have a problem -and an estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants – is because Republicans have shut down the process to become a legal citizen. They prevented the appointments and funding for judges and immigration courts.
Long Island is not immune from the issue. In the past decade there has been an enormous increase in the population of immigrants – a factor in the rise of bias crimes in Suffolk. There is still a large agricultural industry here. According to Joe Gergela, executive director of the Long Island Farm Bureau, agriculture makes up 6 percent of Long Island’s economy and employs 7,000 to 8,000 employees of which 60 percent may be undocumented, if the national average holds. There are also any number of landscapers, and restaurant and hospitality workers.
From a business perspective, immigrants keep Long Island’s economy afloat, says Matthew Crosson, president of the Long Island Association, a consortium of businesses and community groups that promotes development in the region. He argues that without them, countless restaurants and landscaping businesses would close.
“The reality is, given the outflow of younger people on Long Island, those jobs simply would not be done in this community,” he says. “Anybody who says that there are plenty of Long Islanders who could be filling those jobs is just incorrect factually. That is not the case.”
This nation was built upon immigration – as President Obama noted in outlining his plan January 29 at Del Sol High School, Las Vegas, Nevada, to reform a system that has become broken, archaic and counter-productive to the economic and social interests of the nation.
“When we talk about that in the abstract, it’s easy sometimes for the discussion to take on a feeling of ‘us’ versus ‘them.’ And when that happens, a lot of folks forget that most of ‘us’ used to be ‘them.’ We forget that. (Applause.) It’s really important for us to remember our history. Unless you’re one of the first Americans, a Native American, you came from someplace else.”
Obama has proposed commonsense solutions (where has that term been used before? oh yes, gun control, where all of a sudden, commonsense controls on assault weapons and high-capacity ammo clips are subordinated to incarcerating the mentally ill and controlling violent video games and movies).
Obama, ever the optimist, has said that the time is now, that the opportunity has never been as bright because Republicans see a political advantage in seeming to do something now.
Progressives need to be suspicious.
“We need Congress to act on a comprehensive approach that finally deals with the 11 million undocumented immigrants who are in this country right now.
“The good news is that – for the first time in many years – Republicans and Democrats seem ready to tackle this problem together. Members of both parties, in both chambers, are actively working on a solution. And yesterday, a bi-partisan group of Senators announced their principles for comprehensive immigration reform, which are very much in line with the principles I’ve proposed and campaigned on for the last few years. At this moment, it looks like there’s a genuine desire to get this done soon. And that’s very encouraging.”
He laid out the principles:
To “stay focused on enforcement. That means continuing to strengthen security at our borders. It means cracking down more forcefully on businesses that knowingly hire undocumented workers. To be fair, most businesses want to do the right thing, but a lot of them have a hard time figuring out who’s here legally, who’s not. So we need to implement a national system that allows businesses to quickly and accurately verify someone’s employment status. And if they still knowingly hire undocumented workers, then we need to ramp up the penalties.
“Second, we have to deal with the 11 million individuals who are here illegally. We all agree that these men and women should have to earn their way to citizenship. But for comprehensive immigration reform to work, it must be clear from the outset that there is a pathway to citizenship. (Applause.)
“We’ve got to lay out a path — a process that includes passing a background check, paying taxes, paying a penalty, learning English, and then going to the back of the line, behind all the folks who are trying to come here legally. That’s only fair, right? (Applause.)
“So that means it won’t be a quick process but it will be a fair process. And it will lift these individuals out of the shadows and give them a chance to earn their way to a green card and eventually to citizenship. (Applause.)
“And the third principle is we’ve got to bring our legal immigration system into the 21st century because it no longer reflects the realities of our time. (Applause.) For example, if you are a citizen, you shouldn’t have to wait years before your family is able to join you in America. You shouldn’t have to wait years. (Applause.)
“If you’re a foreign student who wants to pursue a career in science or technology, or a foreign entrepreneur who wants to start a business with the backing of American investors, we should help you do that here. Because if you succeed, you’ll create American businesses and American jobs. You’ll help us grow our economy. You’ll help us strengthen our middle class.
“So that’s what comprehensive immigration reform looks like: smarter enforcement; a pathway to earned citizenship; improvements in the legal immigration system so that we continue to be a magnet for the best and the brightest all around the world. It’s pretty straightforward.
“The question now is simple: Do we have the resolve as a people, as a country, as a government to finally put this issue behind us? I believe that we do. I believe that we do. (Applause.) I believe we are finally at a moment where comprehensive immigration reform is within our grasp.”
But the President acknowledged that immigration reform has always ignited passions, but he called for rising above it and creating a pathway – an arduous one that involves criminal background checks and paying fines and back taxes – to “earning” legal citizenship.
“So in the coming weeks, as the idea of reform becomes more real and the debate becomes more heated, and there are folks who are trying to pull this thing apart…. remember that this is not just a debate about policy. It’s about people. It’s about men and women and young people who want nothing more than the chance to earn their way into the American story,” the President said.
There will be a lot of misinformation about what is being proposed (much in the same way the gun control debate is being cast as “they are taking our guns” or they are overturning the Second Amendment.
So here is a fact sheet outlining President Obama’s plan to “Fix our Broken Immigration System so Everyone Plays by the Rules, which provides for a means for families to stay together, for a legal status while individuals go through a long, arduous path to citizenship (involving criminal background checks and payment of fines and back-taxes).
White House Fact Sheet on Obama’s Proposal for Comprehensive Immigration Reform
“America’s immigration system is broken. Too many employers game the system by hiring undocumented workers and there are 11 million people living in the shadows. Neither is good for the economy or the country,” a fact sheet provided by the White House states.
“It is time to act to fix the broken immigration system in a way that requires responsibility from everyone —both from the workers here illegally and those who hire them—and guarantees that everyone is playing by the same rules.
“President Obama’s commonsense immigration reform proposal has four parts. First, continue to strengthen our borders. Second, crack down on companies that hire undocumented workers. Third, hold undocumented immigrants accountable before they can earn their citizenship; this means requiring undocumented workers to pay their taxes and a penalty, move to the back of the line, learn English, and pass background checks. Fourth, streamline the legal immigration system for families, workers, and employers.
“Together we can build a fair, effective and commonsense immigration system that lives up to our heritage as a nation of laws and a nation of immigrants.”
The key principles the President believes should be included in commonsense immigration reform are:
Continuing to Strengthen Border Security: President Obama has doubled the number of Border Patrol agents since 2004 and today border security is stronger than it has ever been. But there is more work to do. The President’s proposal gives law enforcement the tools they need to make our communities safer from crime. And by enhancing our infrastructure and technology, the President’s proposal continues to strengthen our ability to remove criminals and apprehend and prosecute national security threats.
Cracking Down on Employers Hiring Undocumented Workers: Our businesses should only employ people legally authorized to work in the United States. Businesses that knowingly employ undocumented workers are exploiting the system to gain an advantage over businesses that play by the rules. The President’s proposal is designed to stop these unfair hiring practices and hold these companies accountable. At the same time, this proposal gives employers who want to play by the rules a reliable way to verify that their employees are here legally.
Earned Citizenship: It is just not practical to deport 11 million undocumented immigrants living within our borders. The President’s proposal provides undocumented immigrants a legal way to earn citizenship that will encourage them to come out of the shadows so they can pay their taxes and play by the same rules as everyone else. Immigrants living here illegally must be held responsible for their actions by passing national security and criminal background checks, paying taxes and a penalty, going to the back of the line, and learning English before they can earn their citizenship. There will be no uncertainty about their ability to become U.S. citizens if they meet these eligibility criteria. The proposal will also stop punishing innocent young people brought to the country through no fault of their own by their parents and give them a chance to earn their citizenship more quickly if they serve in the military or pursue higher education.
Streamlining Legal Immigration: Our immigration system should reward anyone who is willing to work hard and play by the rules. For the sake of our economy and our security, legal immigration should be simple and efficient. The President’s proposal attracts the best minds to America by providing visas to foreign entrepreneurs looking to start businesses here and helping the most promising foreign graduate students in science and math stay in this country after graduation, rather than take their skills to other countries. The President’s proposal will also reunify families in a timely and humane manner.
Continuing to Strengthen Border Security
Strengthen border security and infrastructure. The President’s proposal strengthens and improves infrastructure at ports of entry, facilitates public-private partnerships aimed at increasing investment in foreign visitor processing, and continues supporting the use of technologies that help to secure the land and maritime borders of the United States.
Combat transnational crime. The President’s proposal creates new criminal penalties dedicated to combating transnational criminal organizations that traffic in drugs, weapons, and money, and that smuggle people across the borders. It also expands the scope of current law to allow for the forfeiture of these organizations’ criminal tools and proceeds. Through this approach, we will bolster our efforts to deprive criminal enterprises, including those operating along the Southwest border, of their infrastructure and profits.
Improve partnerships with border communities and law enforcement. The President’s proposal expands our ability to work with our cross-border law enforcement partners. Community trust and cooperation are keys to effective law enforcement. To this end, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) will establish border community liaisons along the Southern and Northern borders to improve communication and collaboration with border communities, boost funding to tribal government partners to reduce illegal activity on tribal lands, and strengthen training on civil rights and civil liberties for DHS immigration officers.
Crack down on criminal networks engaging in passport and visa fraud and human smuggling. The President’s proposal creates tough criminal penalties for trafficking in passports and immigration documents and schemes to defraud, including those who prey on vulnerable immigrants through notario fraud. It also strengthens penalties to combat human smuggling rings.
Deporting Criminals. The President’s proposal expands smart enforcement efforts that target convicted criminals in federal or state correctional facilities, allowing us to remove them from the United States at the end of their sentences without re-entering our communities. At the same time, it protects those with a credible fear of returning to their home countries.
Streamline removal of nonimmigrant national security and public safety threats. The President’s proposal creates a streamlined administrative removal process for people who overstay their visas and have been determined to be threats to national security and public safety.
Improve our nation’s immigration courts. The President’s proposal invests in our immigration courts. By increasing the number of immigration judges and their staff, investing in training for court personnel, and improving access to legal information for immigrants, these reforms will improve court efficiency. It allows DHS to better focus its detention resources on public safety and national security threats by expanding alternatives to detention and reducing overall detention costs. It also provides greater protections for those least able to represent themselves.
Cracking Down on Employers Who Hire Undocumented Workers
Mandatory, phased-in electronic employment verification. The President’s proposal provides tools for employers to ensure a legal workforce by using federal government databases to verify that the people they hire are eligible to work in the United States. Penalties for hiring undocumented workers are significantly increased, and new penalties are established for committing fraud and identity theft. The new mandatory program ensures the privacy and confidentiality of all workers’ personal information and includes important procedural protections. Mandatory electronic employment verification would be phased in over five years with exemptions for certain small businesses.
Combat fraud and identity theft. The proposal also mandates a fraud‐resistant, tamper‐resistant Social Security card and requires workers to use fraud‐and tamper‐resistant documents to prove authorization to work in the United States. The proposal also seeks to establish a voluntary pilot program to evaluate new methods to authenticate identity and combat identity theft.
Protections for all workers. The President’s proposal protects workers against retaliation for exercising their labor rights. It increases the penalties for employers who hire undocumented workers to skirt the workplace standards that protect all workers. And it creates a “labor law enforcement fund” to help ensure that industries that employ significant numbers of immigrant workers comply with labor laws.
Pathway to Earned Citizenship
Create a provisional legal status. Undocumented immigrants must come forward and register, submit biometric data, pass criminal background and national security checks, and pay fees and penalties before they will be eligible for a provisional legal status. Agricultural workers and those who entered the United States as children would be eligible for the same program. Individuals must wait until the existing legal immigration backlogs are cleared before getting in line to apply for lawful permanent residency (i.e. a “green card”), and ultimately United States citizenship. Consistent with current law, people with provisional legal status will not be eligible for welfare or other federal benefits, including subsidies or tax credits under the new health care law.
Create strict requirements to qualify for lawful permanent resident status. Those applying for green cards must pay their taxes, pass additional criminal background and national security checks, register for Selective Service (where applicable), pay additional fees and penalties, and learn English and U.S. civics. As under current law, five years after receiving a green card, individuals will be eligible to apply for U.S. citizenship like every other legal permanent resident.
Earned citizenship for DREAMers. Children brought here illegally through no fault of their own by their parents will be eligible for earned citizenship. By going to college or serving honorably in the Armed Forces for at least two years, these children should be given an expedited opportunity to earn their citizenship. The President’s proposal brings these undocumented immigrants out of the shadows.
Create administrative and judicial review. An individual whose provisional lawful status has been revoked or denied, or whose application for adjustment has been denied, will have the opportunity to seek administrative and judicial review of those decisions.
Provide new resources to combat fraud. The President’s proposal authorizes funding to enable DHS, the Department of State, and other relevant federal agencies to establish fraud prevention programs that will provide training for adjudicators, allow regular audits of applications to identify patterns of fraud and abuse, and incorporate other proven fraud prevention measures.
Streamlining Legal Immigration
Keep Families Together. The proposal seeks to eliminate existing backlogs in the family-sponsored immigration system by recapturing unused visas and temporarily increasing annual visa numbers. The proposal also raises existing annual country caps from 7 percent to 15 percent for the family-sponsored immigration system. It also treats same-sex families as families by giving U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents the ability to seek a visa on the basis of a permanent relationship with a same-sex partner. The proposal also revises current unlawful presence bars and provides broader discretion to waive bars in cases of hardship.
Cut Red Tape for Employers. The proposal also eliminates the backlog for employment-sponsored immigration by eliminating annual country caps and adding additional visas to the system. Outdated legal immigration programs are reformed to meet current and future demands by exempting certain categories from annual visa limitations.
Enhance travel and tourism. The Administration is committed to increasing U.S. travel and tourism by facilitating legitimate travel while maintaining our nation’s security. Consistent with the President’s Executive Order on travel and tourism, the President’s proposal securely streamlines visa and foreign visitor processing. It also strengthens law enforcement cooperation while maintaining the program’s robust counterterrorism and criminal information sharing initiatives. It facilitates more efficient travel by allowing greater flexibility to designate countries for participation in the Visa Waiver Program, which allows citizens of designated countries to visit the United States without obtaining a visa. And finally it permits the State Department to waive interview requirements for certain very low-risk visa applicants, permitting resources to be focused on higher risk applicants and creates a pilot for premium visa processing.
“Staple” green cards to advanced STEM diplomas. The proposal encourages foreign graduate students educated in the United States to stay here and contribute to our economy by “stapling” a green card to the diplomas of science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) PhD and Master’s Degree graduates from qualified U.S. universities who have found employment in the United States. It also requires employers to pay a fee that will support education and training to grow the next generation of American workers in STEM careers.
Create a “startup visa” for job-creating entrepreneurs. The proposal allows foreign entrepreneurs who attract financing from U.S. investors or revenue from U.S. customers to start and grow their businesses in the United States, and to remain permanently if their companies grow further, create jobs for American workers, and strengthen our economy.
Expand opportunities for investor visas and U.S. economic development. The proposal permanently authorizes immigrant visa opportunities for regional center (pooled investment) programs; provides incentives for visa requestors to invest in programs that support national priorities, including economic development in rural and economically depressed regions ; adds new measures to combat fraud and national security threats; includes data collection on economic impact; and creates a pilot program for state and local government officials to promote economic development.
Create a new visa category for employees of federal national security science and technology laboratories. The proposal creates a new visa category for a limited number of highly-skilled and specialized immigrants to work in federal science and technology laboratories on critical national security needs after being in the United States. for two years and passing rigorous national security and criminal background checks.
Better addresses humanitarian concerns. The proposal streamlines immigration law to better protect vulnerable immigrants, including those who are victims of crime and domestic violence. It also better protects those fleeing persecution by eliminating the existing limitations that prevent qualified individuals from applying for asylum.
Encourage integration. The proposal promotes earned citizenship and efforts to integrate immigrants into their new American communities linguistically, civically, and economically.
Karen Rubin, Long Island Populist Examiner
© 2013 News & Photo Features Syndicate, a division of Workstyles, Inc. All rights reserved. For editorial feature and photo information, go to www.news-photos-features.com or email firstname.lastname@example.org. ‘Like’ us on facebook.com/NewsPhotoFeatures.